Brookhaven NY FSBO Homes (77)

Sort By

List
Map

We have homes for sale by owner in Brookhaven, NY. The median list price in Brookhaven, NY is $307,918 and the average price per square foot is $27,787.

Homes For Sale

$709,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,489 Sqft
1.45 Acres(Lot)

21 West Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY

Welcome to 21 west bartlett rd, a tucked away and unexpected treat. if you are seeking tranquility in a natural... Read More

Homes For Sale

$749,990

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,562 Sqft
0.8 Acre(Lot)

10 Trout Ponds Court, Brookhaven, NY

Beautiful move in ready home at end of cul-de-sac in the coveted brookhaven hamlet. fully remodeled in 2018.... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$449,000

3 Bed
1 Bath
1,255 Sqft

53 Mulford Street, Brookhaven, NY

Discover the potential in this charming two-story home located on a quiet residential block. this property... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$517,999

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,190 Sqft
0.21 Acre(Lot)

70 Propose Road, Shirley, NY

Welcome to this charming and beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch-style home. featuring a spacious and... Read More

Homes For Sale

$780,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
2,836 Sqft
0.75 Acre(Lot)

1 Beaver Court, Brookhaven, NY

Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 3-bath raised ranch nestled on a 3/4 acre lot framed by mature... Read More

Homes For Sale

$749,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,100 Sqft
0.33 Acre(Lot)

21 Highview Boulevard, Brookhaven, NY

A rare opportunity of a possible mother/daughter awaits you in this beautiful hi-ranch built in 1964 with a... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$625,000

3 Bed
1 Bath
1,300 Sqft
0.69 Acre(Lot)

5 Hearth Lane, Brookhaven, NY

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 1 bath ranch. step inside to find a spacious formal living... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$599,900

2 Bed
3 Bath
0.25 Acre(Lot)

347 S Country Road, Brookhaven, NY

Welcome to this charming and recently updated 2-bedroom ranch, nestled on a spacious property perfect for... Read More

Homes For Sale

$795,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
3,447 Sqft
8.48 Acres(Lot)

5550 W Yearling Drive, Beverly Hills, NY

Rare pine ridge pool home on 8.48 acres with equestrian trail access! nestled on 8.48 acres in the sought-after... Read More

Homes For Sale

$799,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
2,280 Sqft
0.35 Acre(Lot)

11930 W Bayshore Drive, Crystal River, NY

Welcome to this beautiful waterfront home located on dixie bay in the picturesque crystal river. this stunning... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$495,000

3 Bed
1 Bath
1,352 Sqft
0.4 Acre(Lot)

2761 Montauk Highway, Brookhaven, NY

Welcome to 2761 montauk highway, brookhaven! discover the warmth and style of this charming home, nestled in... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$695,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,029 Sqft
0.39 Acre(Lot)

158 Donegan Avenue, East Patchogue, NY

This charming cape-style home nestled in the heart of east patchogue offers an impressive 2,029 square feet of... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$499,000

3 Bed
1 Bath
1,057 Sqft
0.66 Acre(Lot)

45 Trainor Avenue, Center Moriches, NY

Charming ranch with in-ground pool in center moriches... welcome to this inviting 3 bedroom/1 bathroom ranch... Read More

Homes For Sale

$1,799,000

4 Bed
4 Bath
2,245 Sqft

301 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove, NY

Oceanfront 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom beach house with dual kitchens & expansive views just steps to the sand!... Read More

Homes For Sale

$1,600,000

6 Bed
5 Bath
6,101 Sqft
1.9 Acres(Lot)

5 Marina Lane, East Patchogue, NY

This stunning 14-room, 6-bedroom, 4.5-bath, 6,100 sqft ranch-style home, built in 2001, offers breathtaking... Read More

Homes For Sale

$999,000

4 Bed
2 Bath
1,800 Sqft
0.18 Acre(Lot)

1 Spindrift Walk, Davis Park, NY

1 spindrift walk is a contemporary ocean view coastal retreat with 360 degrees of bay and ocean views, offering... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$489,999

4 Bed
2 Bath
9,741 Sqft
0.23 Acre(Lot)

122 Longfellow Drive, Mastic Beach, NY

Cape 4 large bedroom,(2br on the first floor & 2 br on the 2nd floor)2 bathrooms,living room, dinning room, eat... Read More

Homes For Sale

$875,000

4 Bed
1 Bath
820 Sqft
0.06 Acre(Lot)

236 Sea Walk, Cherry Grove, NY

Charming beach house on the west end of the grove on a quiet, lovely walk! 4 bedrooms, open living dinning with... Read More

Homes For Sale

$840,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,018 Sqft

103 Greene Walk Walk, Cherry Grove, NY

Escape to your own private piece of paradise! this charming 3 bedroom, 2 full bathroom home offers the perfect... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$1,200,000

5 Bed
3 Bath
3,791 Sqft
0.92 Acre(Lot)

15 Miles Lane, Mount Sinai, NY

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 5-bedroom, 3-bath colonial nestled on a shy acre in the sought-after... Read More

First
1
2
3
4
Last

Brookhaven - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

Homes For Sale By Owner in Brookhaven 1505

	Average Price
1 Bed Homes For Sale in Brookhaven (2)	$ 309,950
2 Bed Homes For Sale in Brookhaven (133)	$ 435,619
3 Bed Homes For Sale in Brookhaven (529)	$ 590,120
4 Bed Homes For Sale in Brookhaven (541)	$ 746,828
5+ Bed Homes For Sale in Brookhaven (253)	$ 2,464,058

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 909,315

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

1497

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 418

Condos For Sale By Owner in Brookhaven 241

	Average Price
1 Bed Condos For Sale in Brookhaven (25)	$ 315,910
2 Bed Condos For Sale in Brookhaven (170)	$ 458,112
3 Bed Condos For Sale in Brookhaven (43)	$ 554,650
4 Bed Condos For Sale in Brookhaven (2)	$ 774,995
5+ Bed Condos For Sale in Brookhaven (1)	$ 1,299,900

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 795,014

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

241

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 374

Townhomes For Sale By Owner in Brookhaven 8

	Average Price
1 Bed Townhomes For Sale in Brookhaven (1)	$ 385,000
2 Bed Townhomes For Sale in Brookhaven (5)	$ 430,980
3 Bed Townhomes For Sale in Brookhaven (2)	$ 492,000

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 712,163

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 339

Land For Sale By Owner in Brookhaven 152

	Average Price
Land For Sale in Brookhaven (152)	$ 648,070

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 648,070

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

152

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ N/A

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Brookhaven, New York

Currently there are 1,505 homes for sale, 241 condos and apartments for sale, 152 vacant land for sale and 8 townhomes for sale in Brookhaven

Currently Brookhaven has 1,906 properties on the market for sale. The inventory was last updated 07/11/2025. Of these properties, 1,505 single family homes are for sale by their owners in Brookhaven, and 241 condos are for sale by their owners in Brookhaven. The average price of the single family homes for sale in Brookhaven, is $909,315, the average condo price in Brookhaven, is $795,014. The average price per square foot of the active inventory is $283. This is based the living area square footage.

Over the last year, there have been 0 of properties sold in Brookhaven. Of these properties, 0 single family homes have sold by their owners in Brookhaven, and 0 condos have sold by their owners in Brookhaven. The average sales price of the single family homes sold in Brookhaven, is $. Single family homes have been selling for per square foot of living area. The average sales price of the condos for sale in Brookhaven, is $. Condos have been selling for per square foot of living area.

The most active subdivisions with listings for sale in Brookhaven, are:

If you are thinking of selling your Brookhaven home, try our flat fee listing service, Our list fees start at $449, and may save you $15,000 in real estate commissions. Click here to start saving.

Disclaimer: Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers/lessees are advised to confirm all information IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. The MLS may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Participants and/or the MLS from liability.
This data up-to-date as of 07/11/2025

Brookhaven NY FSBO Homes (77)

21 West Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY

10 Trout Ponds Court, Brookhaven, NY

53 Mulford Street, Brookhaven, NY

70 Propose Road, Shirley, NY

1 Beaver Court, Brookhaven, NY

21 Highview Boulevard, Brookhaven, NY

5 Hearth Lane, Brookhaven, NY

347 S Country Road, Brookhaven, NY

5550 W Yearling Drive, Beverly Hills, NY

11930 W Bayshore Drive, Crystal River, NY

2761 Montauk Highway, Brookhaven, NY

158 Donegan Avenue, East Patchogue, NY

45 Trainor Avenue, Center Moriches, NY

301 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove, NY

5 Marina Lane, East Patchogue, NY

1 Spindrift Walk, Davis Park, NY

122 Longfellow Drive, Mastic Beach, NY

236 Sea Walk, Cherry Grove, NY

103 Greene Walk Walk, Cherry Grove, NY

15 Miles Lane, Mount Sinai, NY

Nearby Cities

Popular Cities

Nearby Counties

Property Types

Brookhaven - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Brookhaven, New York

For Sale By Owner California

Statistics Bottom Ads 2

For Sale By Owner Idaho

Statistics Bottom Ads 3

For Sale By Owner Washington

For Sale By Owner Louisiana

Statistics Bottom Ads 4

YouTube Video