Shelter Island NY FSBO Homes (14)

Learn More About Shelter Island, New York

Currently there are and 20 homes for sale in Shelter Island

Currently Shelter Island has 20 properties on the market for sale. The inventory was last updated 04/28/2025. Of these properties, 20 single family homes are for sale by their owners in Shelter Island, and 0 condos are for sale by their owners in Shelter Island. The average price of the single family homes for sale in Shelter Island, is $2,464,246, the average condo price in Shelter Island, is $. The average price per square foot of the active inventory is $1. This is based the living area square footage.

Over the last year, there have been 0 of properties sold in Shelter Island. Of these properties, 0 single family homes have sold by their owners in Shelter Island, and 0 condos have sold by their owners in Shelter Island. The average sales price of the single family homes sold in Shelter Island, is $. Single family homes have been selling for per square foot of living area. The average sales price of the condos for sale in Shelter Island, is $. Condos have been selling for per square foot of living area.

The most active subdivisions with listings for sale in Shelter Island, are:

If you are thinking of selling your Shelter Island home, try our flat fee listing service, Our list fees start at $449, and may save you $15,000 in real estate commissions. Click here to start saving.

Disclaimer: Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers/lessees are advised to confirm all information IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. The MLS may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Participants and/or the MLS from liability.
This data up-to-date as of 04/28/2025